Post

Changing perspective: Einstein between Kant’s certainties and Hume’s doubts

We can imagine the context in which Albert Einstein’s Gedankenexperimente (thought experiments) were born: the study of philosophy. To dismantle the idea that space and time were the same for everyone, the young physicist had to engage in an intellectual duel with two giants of thought: Immanuel Kant and David Hume.

Kant’s legacy: space as an objective necessity
From an early age, Einstein had studied Kant in depth, and from him he learned a fundamental concept: we are not passive spectators of the world; our mind does not simply record reality, but actively processes it. Kant argued that space and time are internal structures of the mind, the necessary conditions for having any experience at all. See also my post Kant and Space.
This idea was crucial for Einstein because it helped him understand that science is not merely a collection of data, but a construction of reason. However, the limit of Kant’s thought lay in the claim that these structures must be rigid and identical for every rational being. For Kant, space was only the one described in Euclid’s geometry books, and time was a universal flow, the same for everyone.

Hume’s inspiration: the courage to doubt
When Einstein began working on his thought experiments about light, he realized that Kant’s ‘fixed rules’ no longer worked. To move beyond them, David Hume’s philosophy was certainly of help.
Hume was a radical philosopher who urged people to take nothing for granted. His motto was simple: if a concept cannot be verified by the senses or through a concrete measurement, then it is suspicious. Hume taught Einstein to have the courage to doubt concepts that seem obvious to ‘common sense’. Einstein was aware that no one had ever measured ‘absolute time’, flowing identically for all; it was only a belief grounded in habit, not in physical evidence.

The synthesis: Relativity is born
Without the support of Hume’s skepticism, Einstein might not have had the audacity to question time. He understood that if the speed of light must remain constant, then time and space must be able to change depending on the speed of the observer (the principles of Special Relativity).
In this way, Einstein went beyond Kant using Hume’s method: he retained the Kantian idea that the mind must create categories to read the world, but he showed that these categories are not immutable. Space and time are not unchanging a priori forms, but physical quantities that can contract or stretch.

Einstein was thus a philosopher among physicists. He learned from Kant that the mind must anticipate reality (that is, describe it even before physical observations) with a coherent theoretical model, but he learned from Hume that no idea is untouchable. In this way, he found the courage to understand that if old theories had become full of gaps or incapable of describing the universe in a unified (that is, invariant) way, one had to have the audacity to redesign the very structure of thought itself, even before the facts forced it.


Albert Einstein

please, rate this post

Kant and Space

The redefinition of the concept of space is one of the revolutionary foundations thought of Immanuel Kant (1724-1804): the abandonment of the common, Newtonian-derived idea of space as an absolute entity or an objective ‘container’ of reality. Kant addresses the problem within the Transcendental Aesthetic, the section of the Critique of Pure Reason devoted to sensibility. He distinguishes a metaphysical exposition, which establishes the a priori nature of space, and a transcendental exposition, which derives from it space’s role as a condition of the possibility of experience and of geometry.

Space as Pure Intuition
In contrast to empiricists, Kant argues that space cannot be derived from experience. In order to perceive an object as located in a place different from that occupied by another object, or simply as ‘external’ to us, we must already presuppose the representation of space. Therefore, space is not a general concept constructed by abstraction, but a pure a priori intuition:
– intuition: because it is not a logical construction, but an immediate and singular representation within which we place sensory data
– a priori: because it precedes every sensation and is its necessary condition.

Transcendental Subjectivity
This is the core of Kant’s ‘Copernican Revolution’. Kant claims that space does not belong to things in themselves (noumena), but is the form of outer sense. In other words, it is the way in which the human subject is structured to receive information from the world. This leads to a fundamental epistemological distinction:
– transcendental ideality: if we abstract from the knowing subject, space is nothing as a thing in itself; it has no autonomous existence outside our faculties and is not a determination of noumena
– empirical reality: at the same time, space has objective validity for all phenomena (for every possible experience), for every object that could ever present itself to our senses.

The Foundation of Geometry
Kant uses this view to explain, in a scientific context, the nature of geometry’s synthetic a priori judgments. He is, of course, considering only Euclidean geometry as a description of the space of experience, having lived half a century before Bernhard Riemann (1826-1866) and the development of elliptic geometry. If geometry is the science that studies the properties of space, and if space is the a priori form of our mind, then geometrical theorems will be universally and necessarily valid for all objects of experience. In short, geometry applies to the physical world not because the world is ‘geometrical by nature’, but because we can perceive the world only through a spatial structure that we ourselves project onto phenomenal reality.

In conclusion, for Kant space is not an object of physical investigation like others, but the condition of possibility of our experience. Without this subjective structure, the perception of the external world would be impossible.
Clearly, this Kantian interpretation should be reconsidered in light of the implications of elliptic geometry and of General Relativity, and of the consequences of Special Relativity. In General Relativity, Einstein showed that space is not merely a passive state of possibility, but a dynamic physical entity that bends under the influence of mass: space acts on matter, and matter acts on space. Special Relativity undermines the objectivity of spatial extensions: lengths are measures of objects, but ultimately they are measures of the spatial coordinate component parallel to the relative velocity between reference frames, which is not invariant. The requirement, as noted above, that this structure (space) be objective stands in sharp contradiction with the physical reality described by General and Special Relativity.

Quite simply, while Kant wanted to base science on philosophy, Einstein demonstrated that it is philosophy that must bow (and bend with General Relativity!) before the physical evidence of reality.

see also the post:
link  Changing perspective: Einstein between Kant’s certainties and Hume’s doubts


Immanuel Kant

please, rate this post

How lightning works

An interesting explanation is given in Ottavio Vittori’s excellent book L’atmosfera del pianeta Terra (Zanichelli, 1992), from which the introductory chapter on this powerful electrical phenomenon is attached with the best intentions.
It’s written in italian.

pdf  Vittori 1992_L’atmosfera del pianeta Terra


Lightnings

please, rate this post

Understanding the Sizes : 4 – galaxy clusters and beyond

Exploring beyond our galaxy, to be able to reach the edges of the known universe with measurements that can be perceived, it is necessary to change scale again compared with the previous post on the Milky Way. Over there, the distances involved become almost impossible to truly understand, they are so mindblowing!

Let us now consider our galaxy to be 1 millimeter across. We are part of a ‘local’ group of galaxies made up of more than a hundred smaller galaxies (of which only one is of significant size, the Triangulum Galaxy, known as M33, see Figure 1), and a large spiral galaxy broadly similar to ours, Andromeda (Figure 2), which is about 2.5 cm away. Andromeda is the most distant cosmological object that can be seen with the naked eye (see also my post References for laymen: angles in the sky).


Figure 1 – triangle galaxy M33 (credits: Nasa, Esa e M. Durbin, J. Dalcanton e B. F. Williams, University of Washington)

Triangle galaxy M33

 

Figure 2 – Andromeda galaxy (image credit: Westend61 via Getty Images)


Andromeda is more extended but less massive than our galaxy. It’s getting closer to us (or rather we’re getting closer to each other) at about 400,000 km/h, on our new scale, less than four thousandths of a millimeter (about one hundredth the thickness of a hair) in a million years. In other words, in 4–5 billion years the two galaxies will merge, still in a collisionless way (we demonstrated this here, §1, not for newbies), and will probably turn into a giant elliptical galaxy (like NGC 1600 in Figure 3) after a few more billion years. However, recent measurements from the Gaia* satellite reduce the probability of this merger happening on such ‘short’ timescales, even though it is inevitable that it will occur.

* The Gaia satellite is an astrometric mission of the European Space Agency (ESA), launched in 2013 to map the Milky Way in 3D. It orbits around the Lagrange point L2 (see my post The three-body problem and the five Lagrangian points), and has created the most precise stellar catalog of more than 2 billion stars around us, measuring their positions, motions, brightness, and chemical composition.


Figure 3 – NGC 1600 by HST, it has a diameter of about 120.000 light -years, or about 1.2 mm on our scale (credits: A. Quillen, University of Rochester, G. Bower, CSC/STScI, and G. Rieke, Steward Observatory/University of Arizona)

NGC 1600


The Local Group of galaxies (see the 3D schematic in Figure 4) has a radius of about 3 cm on the adopted scale, and is surrounded in an “homogeneous” way by similar structures. For example, in Figure 5 a radius of 33 cm is considered on the same scale, and in Figure 6 a radius of about 1.5 m. Proceeding in an analogous way, one can reach the limit of the observable universe (that is, before redshift completely prevents sources from being detected) which, on the adopted scale, can be taken to be at a distance of just over 4 meters.


Figure 4 – Local Group of galaxies (source starwalk.space)

local galaxies cluster

 

Figure 5 – Virgo Supercluster, along with 100 other galaxy groups (source starwalk.space)

Virgo Supercluster

 

Figure 6 – Laniakea Supercluster which includes almost 100.000 galaxies more than ours (source starwalk.space)

Super Supercluster


We have reached the limit of the current theory of the standard cosmological model. It is a theory, based on creation from nothing through an initial Big Bang, which is strongly supported by observations but also has major gaps in explaining other evidence.
Our journey therefore stops right at the limit of ‘measurable’ findings grounded in commonly accepted theories; beyond this point, it becomes epistemology rather than cosmology.

 

Previous episodes:
Understanding the Sizes : 3 – Milky Way
Understanding the Sizes : 2 – Solar System
Understanding the Sizes : 1 – Earth and Moon

please, rate this post

Understanding the Sizes : 3 – Milky Way

The Milky Way is our galaxy: a gravitationally bound structure that includes about 100 billion stars and an enormous amount of gas (essentially atomic hydrogen), with an approximate shape of a rotating disk, which, of course, we can only imagine and not actually see, since we are inside it (our view towards the galactic centre is known, see Figure 1, even if it is increasingly difficult to observe, due to atmospheric pollution, especially light pollution.). See Figure 2 for a photo of a similar example. The stars, gas, and dust that make up the disk rotate in the sense that they orbit around the roughly spherical central nucleus (the bulge), which instead is not rotating (its stars have chaotic motions).


Figure 1 -Milky Way as seen from Earth (my photo)

Milky Way

 

Figure 2 – example of a galaxy similar to the Milky Way: NGC 6744, taken at the European Southern Observatory’s La Silla Observatory in Chile (image credits: ESO)

Galaxy like Milky Way


To understand the sizes, it is necessary to change scale again compared with the previous post on the Solar System: the quantities involved become increasingly difficult to ‘grasp’. We have seen that Sun light takes about 4 hours to reach Neptune, the outermost planet of the Solar System. The star closest to us is Proxima Centauri (a red dwarf in a triple star system), about 4 light-years away. We therefore choose the light-year as the unit for this new distance scale, imagining 1 light-year as equal to 1 millimeter. Then Proxima Centauri is about 4 mm from the Sun (of course, since the difference is only a few light-minutes compared with 4 light-years, Earth and the Sun that Earth orbits can be considered at essentially the same distance).

All these stars orbit around the nucleus but also have their own independent motions, which are collisionless (we demonstrated this here, §1, not for newbies), a remarkable fact given the number of bodies, and in contrast, for example, with a collection of gas molecules in a container, which instead undergo continuous collisions (which determine its pressure and temperature). But compared with a gas, the distances between the components in a galaxy are immensely larger.

In the new scale we have adopted, the radius of the galactic disk is about 105 meters (about 105,000 light-years), and our position is about 26 meters from the center. In Figure 3 the drawing schematically outlines one possible configuration and the proportions. Our linear speed is about 790,000 km/h and we complete one orbit in about 250 million years, so on our scale, despite the crazy speed, we move only about 1.5 cm in a thousand years, in this 105-meter-radius disk. Since the Sun and Earth formed, about 4.5 billion years ago, we have made about 18 revolutions around the galactic nucleus.


Figure 3 – schematic drawing of the Milky Way and its proportions (gases beyond the star limit are not drawn but they are gravitationally relevant; source starwalk.space)

MIlky Way sketch


The disk of our galaxy is made up of several arms, where the concentration of stars is higher, and a more rectilinear component that originates from the central nucleus, from which the arms branch out, as schematized in Figure 3. A galaxy of this kind is called a ‘barred spiral’ and its shape when seen edge-on is similar to the example in Figure 4.
In a future post we will talk about the central black hole and the star-forming regions.


Figure 4 – Example of a spiral galaxy seen edge-on, ESO 121-6 (source: HST by ESA/Hubble & NASA)

Galaxy edge on Eso121-6


As a final remark, note that nearly all the stars visible to the naked eye belong to the Sun’s local stellar neighborhood, as highlighted in Figure 3. It’s a tiny region compared with the size of the whole Milky Way. Most of the Galaxy’s other stars are too faint and/or too obscured by interstellar dust to be seen individually, and instead contribute to the Milky Way’s diffuse glow: a blend of millions to billions of unresolved stars.

 

Next episode:
Understanding the Sizes : 4 – galaxy clusters and beyond

Previous episodes:
Understanding the Sizes : 2 – Solar System
Understanding the Sizes : 1 – Earth and Moon

please, rate this post

Understanding the Sizes : 2 – Solar System

Second episode of the deep dives into the measurements of the universe around us. The first one was about the Earth and the Moon.
This one is about the Solar System, that is, the bodies that orbit the Sun, our star.

The planets classified as such are, in order of increasing orbital radius: Mercury, Venus, Earth, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn, Uranus, Neptune (see Figure 1). Besides these main bodies there are many secondary ones, such as dwarf planet, moons, asteroids, and comets, but we will focus only on the main objects.


Figure 1 – drawing of the sequence of planets of the solar system

Solar System


Since Kepler (1571–1630) we know that orbits are ellipses (see Figure 2), with the Sun located at one of the foci. In reality, eccentricity (i.e.  a – b  with reference to Figure 2) is quite low, about 3%  for Earth and modest for all the planets except Mercury. Other celestial bodies orbiting in the Solar System, such as asteroids (larger ‘rocks’ measuring a few hundred kilometers), also exhibit significant eccentricity (which measures how much their orbit deviates from a circle). For simplicity we will consider circular orbits and a single radius.


Figure 2 – An ellipse is a plane curve surrounding two focal points, such that for all points on the curve, the sum of both distances to the two focal points is a constant ( FP + PF’ = constant for each P on the curve); in this example, the eccentricity is very large, while for the planets it is much smaller; the F points are called foci, a is the semi-major axis, b is the semi-minor axis.

Ellipse


We will not list all of the measurements for these objects, but only a few reference ones. It is important to understand the need to change the reference scale, moving to a larger one, we can no longer use the soccer ball from the previous post. Now let us imagine Earth as a tiny grain of fine sand (0.09 mm), and its distance from the Sun as 1 meter (the radius of its orbit, usually called the astronomical unit, AU).  On this scale, the planet closest to the Sun is Mercury (with a radius 0.38 that of Earth), at about 38 cm. Mars (with a radius 0.52 that of Earth) orbits at about 1.5 m; the gas giants Jupiter (radius 11 times that of Earth, i.e., 0.9 mm on the adopted scale) at about 5 m, and Saturn (radius 9.5 times that of Earth) at about 9.5 m. Uranus and Neptune are very far away, at about 19 m and 30 m respectively. See Figure 3 for a scale diagram.


Figure 3 – a scale diagram of distances in the Solar System

Solar System distances


But what does this one meter of distance, taken as a reference for Earth’s orbit, correspond to? It is about 149 million km, a distance that would take roughly 170 years to cover by car traveling at 100 km/h. Light, which travels at 300,000 km/s (more than 1 billion km/h), takes about 8 minutes to go from the Sun to Earth, and more than 4 hours to reach Neptune.
And how big is the Sun? Its radius is about 670,000 km, so compared with the Earth as a soccer ball model, it would be a sphere with a radius of 11.60 m, roughly the volume of a a five-story building of 400 square meters per floor. Compared with the Earth as a grain of fine sand model, it would be a ‘grain’ of almost 1 cm (9.3 mm).

Earth has one large moon, the Moon; Mars has two small ones, Phobos and Deimos. Jupiter has four major moons (Io, Europa, Ganymede, Callisto, discovered in 1609 by Galileo Galilei, 1564–1642) and 91 smaller ones. Saturn has as many as 146 in total! Practically all moons are in synchronous rotation, meaning they always show the same face to their planet, like our Moon.

Saturn’s rings (Figure 4), made up of countless particles of ice and rock, are more than 30,000 km wide (three times Earth’s diameter) but extremely thin, ranging from a few tens of meters to a few hundreds of meters. For this reason, when they are seen edge-on (about every 15 Earth years), they reflect almost no sunlight and are not visible from Earth.


Figure 4 – Saturn photo by HST (source: NASA, ESA, STScI, Amy Simon NASA-GSFC)

Saturn


Beyond the orbit of Neptune, or on our scale between 30 and 50 meters, lies the Kuiper Belt (named after Gerrit Pieter Kuiper, 1905-1973), which contains thousands of icy bodies, remnants of the formation of the Solar System, including dwarf planets like Pluto, essentially distributed in a volume squashed on the plane of the ecliptic. The so-called heliosphere ends here. An even more external region, the Oort Cloud (named after Jan Oort, 1900-1992), between 2 and 200 km on our scale, has been hypothesized to contain an immense diffusion of ice and rocks, the reservoir from which comets are drawn by the Sun. We can consider it as the outer boundary of the Solar System.

 

Next episodes:
Understanding the Sizes : 3 – Milky Way
Understanding the Sizes : 4 – galaxy clusters and beyond

Previous episode:
Understanding the Sizes : 1 – Earth and Moon

please, rate this post

Understanding the Sizes : 1 – Earth and Moon

In everyday life, we don’t stop to think about the ‘sizes’ of the planet we live in, the Solar System, and the galaxy (Milky Way) in which we orbit with our mothership, Earth.
In a series of insights, we aim to understand the distances and some parameters that characterize these systems. This first one concerns the Earth and its satellite, the Moon (Figure 1).


Figure 1 -the Earth and the Moon

Earth_Moon


The average radius of the Earth (slightly smaller at the poles than at the equator) is approximately 6,370 km, meaning its circumference is approximately 40,000 km. Therefore, an electromagnetic signal traveling at 300,000 km/s would circle the planet 7.5 times in one second.

Here are some interesting measurements to compare:

– The thickness of the troposphere, where virtually all meteorological phenomena occur and almost all water vapor is concentrated, varies from about 8 km (at the poles) to about 20 km (at the equator), or, on average, 14 km. That is, if the Earth were the size of a soccer ball (radius about 11 cm), the troposphere would be roughly the thickness of two sheets of paper (about 0.24 mm).

– The highest mountain (Everest, about 8.8 km) and the deepest ocean (Mariana Trench, about 10.9 km) are of the same order of magnitude as the height of the troposphere. As if to say that if you held that soccer ball in your hand you would almost not notice their presence.

– The Moon, which has a radius of 1,737 km, would be slightly smaller than a tennis ball (radius about 3 cm) compared to the soccer ball sized Earth, see Figure 2. Its average distance from Earth is about 380,000 km, so an electromagnetic signal takes about 1.3 seconds to arrive; in the proportions calculated for the balls, the distance between them would be about 6.5 meters.


Figure 2 – Soccer ball and tennis ball in the proportions of Earth and Moon

balls


– The altitude at which airliners fly, about 10 km, is little more than the thickness of a sheet of paper. Seen from space they appear to crawl more than fly. The International Space Station (ISS) is maintained at an altitude of about 400 km, about 7 mm above the soccer ball, at a speed of about 28,000 km/h, or it would move about 8 mm per minute.

– Considering the Earth’s rotation in 24 hours, the tangential velocity of a point at the equator is almost 1,700 km/h; at our latitudes of about 45°, the speed is just under 1,200 km/h. For this reason, spacecraft launch pads are positioned at low latitudes, near the equator, to take advantage of the higher linear velocity. The escape velocity required to overcome gravitational pull (about 40,000 km/h on Earth) is more easily achieved by exploiting the velocity of the launch point (with a starting direction toward the east for maximum effect, considering that the Earth rotates towards the east and the speeds can add up).
Note that escape velocity is not tied to ‘up’; it’s the minimum speed at a given altitude to be unbound, in any direction, as long as you don’t collide with the planet.

 

Next episodes:
Understanding the Sizes : 2 – Solar System
Understanding the Sizes : 3 – Milky Way
Understanding the Sizes : 4 – galaxy clusters and beyond

please, rate this post

How empty is matter?

Very empty.
Extremely empty.

Let’s consider the elementary constituents, atoms, which then aggregate into molecules to form the matter we know. They consist of a nucleus that represents almost the entire mass, in the form of positively charged protons and neutrons with almost equal mass to protons but without charge, and very light (1/2000 the mass of the proton) negatively charged electrons that ‘orbit’ around the nucleus. Under normal conditions, the electric charges of the protons and electrons of the ‘neutral’ atom balance each other out. All aggregations between atoms occur thanks to the forces of attraction between different charges, whereas, as we know, equal charges repel each other, as is the case with magnetic forces. In the nucleus, protons, although they have the same positive charge and repel each other, are held together by an extremely strong force called the strong nuclear force.


Figure 1 – example of a very imprecise diagram of an atom (source: freepic.com)

false atom


Figure 1 is a typical example of a misrepresentation of an atom, for many reasons, but two are primary: the particles are not ‘balls’ but probability densities, that is, ‘elongated clouds’ rather than ‘balls’; the proportions are monstrously misleading.
This brings us to the topic of this post.
Let’s consider the smallest and simplest atom, the neutral hydrogen atom H (consisting of 1 proton and 1 electron), and the neutral iron atom Fe (the most common isotope is composed of 26 protons, 30 neutrons and 26 electrons). The mass of Fe is therefore about 56 times that of H.
For atomic measurements, we use angstroms (Å, named after the Swedish physicist Anders Jonas Ångström, 1814-1874), equal to one-tenth of a billionth of a meter (10¯¹º m).
We also consider only the nuclei and the minimum distance of the electrons from the nucleus, that is, the radius of their innermost orbit (so the ‘size’ of the entire atom is much larger).
Some actual measurements of these particles are approximately as follows:

AtomNucleusMin distance electronsΔ
H1,7 · 10-5 Å (0,000017 Å)0,5 Å~2.9 · 104
Fe5 · 10-5 Å (0,00005 Å) 1,25 Å~2.5 · 104

So between the nucleus and the innermost orbit of the electrons there are about four orders of magnitude! This is empty space. Obviously, there are electric fields holding everything together, but there are no massive particles, bound or not, in that space, and there can’t be any in any atom, under normal conditions of matter.

Four orders of magnitude means that if the Fe nucleus were the size of a plum (5 cm), there would be empty space up to 1250 meters away. For H, if the nucleus were the size of a grape (17 mm), there would be empty space up to 500 meters away.

What allows matter to be bound in the solid state are the electrical binding forces between atoms, due to the presence/absence of electrons in outermost atomic shells, but that’s another story.
These empty spaces compress only under extreme conditions, for example when matter degenerates in stars that transform into white dwarfs or neutron stars (when the outward force of radiation ceases and gravity compresses the star), reaching unimaginable densities (a grape would have a mass of billions of tons). But that’s another story, too.

please, rate this post

Olbers’ paradox and the dark night sky

Why is the night sky dark?
If universe were infinite, eternal, and static, as Giordano Bruno (1548-1600) claimed, as did cosmology until the early 20th century, adding that it is also populated by stars in a homogeneous manner, the night sky should be bright and not dark. This contradiction was already noted by Johannes Kepler (1571-1630) in 1610 in Dissertatio cum Nuncio Sidereo.
However, the principle was clearly formulated in 1826 by Einrich Wilhelm Olbers (1758-1840), who mathematically demonstrated (see below, optional reasoning which can be skipped) why the night sky should shine according to the cosmology of the time, highlighting a paradox with respect to observation.

Imagining the universe as consisting of spherical shells concentric with respect to our point of observation (see Figure 1), the intensity of radiation received (flux  f ) from a source ( L ) at a distance ( r ) is inversely proportional to the square of the distance:
[1]    f = L / 4 π r²
The number of sources contained in the shell is proportional to the volume, which increases with the square of the distance (by infinitesimal increments
dr = R – r  with reference to Figure 1):
[2]    dn ∝ dV ≈ 4 π r² dr
Therefore, the effects of [1] and [2] compensate each other and each shell contributes with the same intensity, regardless of distance.
The infinitesimal intensity ( dI ) coming from the infinitesimal shell, multiplying [1] and [2], is:
[3]    dI = f dn = n L dr
Integrating [3] gives the total intensity:
[4]    I =∫₀ᴿ n L dr = n L R
Therefore, for  R → ∞, the intensity [4] should become infinite. So something is wrong with the reasoning (hence the paradox).


Figure 1 – sketch of a spherical shell

spherical shell


The observation of the dark night sky is explained in modern terms (based on cosmological standard model) because the universe has existed for a finite time (Big Bang hypothesis) and is expanding (interpretation of the redshift of radiation from remote sources).
In the first case, it is considered that the light from remote sources, which has a finite speed, simply has not reached us yet.

In the second case, redshift, or the shift of light towards longer wavelengths (for example, in the infrared band, beyond the range visible to the eye), prevents the observation of remote sources.
It should also be remembered that the distribution of the intensity of radiation from stellar sources follows a Planckian curve (see Figure 3), which has its maximum in the visible light band. In other words, there are no significant intensities of radiation in a typical stellar source that, moving due to the effect of redshift, could affect this visible band.
In fact, we emphasize that the range of radiation visible to our eyes is very small compared to the entire spectrum of radiation, as shown in Figure 2.
In reality, redshift alone would explain the dark night sky, even if the universe were infinite and without assuming a Big Bang. And even without expansion, if the observed redshift had a different cause.


Figure 2 – full spectrum of radiation with visible band

fulll spectrum

 

Figure 3 – A sketch of a Planckian functions of brightness (intensity of radiation emitted per unit solid angle) for stellar sources with different surface temperatures. That of the Sun is approximately 5700 K.

blackbody

please, rate this post

The Rayleigh scattering and the blue sky

Why is the daytime sky blue?
We need to examine a type of scattering that affects photons from solar radiation when they interact with the molecules that make up the atmosphere, namely nitrogen and oxygen (99% of the components).
This is Rayleigh scattering (named after Nobel Prize winner John William Strutt Rayleigh, 1842-1919), which affects particles smaller than the wavelength of the incident radiation. It is an elastic scattering, so the wavelength of the same radiation is not changed.
We are dealing with photons, but the formula was developed on the basis of classical electromagnetic theory, not quantum theory (which was created after Rayleigh’s death).


Figure 1 – Angular dependence of Rayleigh Scattering
(copyright MLisandra, CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons, here without the formula inscription)


For the explanation we are looking for, the Rayleigh scattering formula can be simplified as follows (see also Figure 1):
[1]    I ~ I₀ (1+cos²γ) / λ⁴
where  I  is the intensity of the scattered radiation,  I₀  is the intensity of the incident radiation with wavelength  λ ,  γ  is the scattering angle of the incident radiation.

We can immediately see that the angle where the intensity  [1]  is lowest is the right angle ( π/2 ), where the cosine is zero (see Figure 2), meaning that the sky is darkest (the blue is most intense) at an angle of 90° to the direction of the Sun.
Furthermore, the dependence on the inverse of the fourth power of  λ suggests that the effects for different wavelengths are significantly different. In fact, blue light is scattered much more than red light, which has a longer wavelength (see Figure 3), making the sky blue. Even shorter wavelengths, such as those of violet, are less intense at source and do not contribute significantly.
At dawn and dusk, blue light is highly scattered by the greater layer of atmosphere it passes through, together with yellow and green light, so red/orange light dominates.

In the case of smaller particles, the cross section and refractive index of the particle are considered, but even if atmospheric gas molecules are treated as point sources, in this case the effects depend on their polarizability due to incident radiation. Those who take photographs using a polarizing filter are familiar with this phenomenon: in fact, by adjusting the filter effect and therefore the polarization, the sky can even become completely black at 90° to the Sun, which can be creative but not very realistic!


Figure 2 – cosine function behaviour

cosine function

Figure 3 – visible band of radiation

visible band of radiation


See also Mie scattering and white clouds.

please, rate this post