From Aristotelian episteme to modern knowledge

In Aristotelian thought, the concept of episteme had a precise profile: it denoted demonstrative knowledge, anchored in first principles and in the necessary causes of phenomena, and capable of ensuring stability over time. The methodological criterion underpinning that framework required theories not merely to save the phenomena—as mathematical astronomy demanded—but to explain them through their causes, without introducing arbitrary postulates. Once validated, such knowledge constituted a structural heritage, meant to endure as a solid foundation for future generations.

In the transition to contemporary science, and particularly in theoretical physics and cosmology over recent decades, we are witnessing a striking asymmetry. On the one hand, the acceleration of research produces a continuous stream of provisional results, often superseded before they can consolidate into a shared framework. On the other hand, at the level of foundations, despite a proliferation of purely mathematical constructs—such as supersymmetry, (super)string theory, and the various models of quantum gravity—there has been no genuine, empirically verified advance for half a century. Fundamental physics is suspended between formally sophisticated but unfalsifiable speculation and the mere confirmation of old predictions.

Cosmology offers the clearest example of this drift. Faced with discrepancies between observational data—such as galaxy rotation curves or the redshift–distance relation on cosmological scales—and the predictions of classical gravitational equations or the standard cosmological model, the prevailing solution is not to revise the models’ assumptions, but to introduce non-baryonic, not directly detectable components. Dark matter and dark energy thus end up accounting for roughly ninety-five percent of the energy density of the universe, while remaining labels lacking not only any experimental confirmation in the laboratory, but even a unified theoretical framework to justify them. Instead of a solid theory, we see a continuous succession of hypothetical candidates and ad hoc models—from WIMPs to axions, from sterile neutrinos to the most exotic scalar fields—formulated after the fact to fill the same anomalies, and invariably disproved or scaled back with each new theoretical proposal or attempt at verification.

From a rigorous epistemological perspective, this approach inverts the classical principle: rather than adapting theory to phenomena, ad hoc corrective parameters are constructed to preserve the mathematical integrity of the model. The dynamic is not unlike the epicycles of the Ptolemaic tradition, in which additional variables served to keep the initial hypothesis standing despite observational anomalies.

The tension becomes even sharper in light of data from the James Webb Space Telescope, whose observations of the high-redshift universe reveal galactic structures too massive and evolved for the timescales predicted by the standard cosmological model. Given such critical issues, methodological rigor would call for extreme caution in treating as established the hypotheses outlined above, which remain, at present, purely conjectural.

The distance separating Aristotelian episteme from modern knowledge therefore lies not in the power of our measuring instruments, but in the status assigned to empirical verification. When a theory requires invisible hypotheses in order not to be falsified by the data, or takes refuge in mathematical architectures with no contact with experiment, the boundary between established knowledge and mere formal modeling becomes blurred. Recovering a clear criterion for distinguishing what has genuinely been demonstrated from what remains a computational convention would be the foremost task of an epistemology that is today evidently absent.

please, rate this post

Modern causality vs. Aristotelian final causality

Some considerations on causality supplementing the study A short essay on causality.

In Aristotelian physics (cf. Physics II), the explanation of a natural process requires the articulation of four distinct causes, which represent its different aspects, separable by logos: the matter of which a thing is made (material cause), the form or essence that defines it (formal cause), the agent that triggers the change (efficient cause), and the purpose for the sake of which the process takes place (final cause). In biological cycles, such as the transition from acorn to oak (Aristotle’s own example), the final cause does not represent an external intention, but an immanent (internal) necessity: the entity realizes its optimal completed form and tends to perpetuate it.

It is precisely in this biological and cyclic domain, however, that the teleological framework (i.e., the orientation of a process toward an end) reveals its primary logical aporia. Subordinating the process to the attainment of the telos creates a circularity within the model: if the acorn’s purpose is the oak tree, but the oak tree’s purpose is to produce new acorns for the preservation of the species, the causal explanation resolves into a recursiveness that describes the repetition of form without explaining its generative mechanism.

The scientific revolution and modern physics have radically deconstructed this framework, demonstrating that teleological scaffolding is superfluous for understanding the dynamics of the physical world. The entire explanation of cosmic order has been reorganized around the efficient cause alone, reinterpreted in terms of conservation laws and fundamental interactions.

The modern reinterpretation of causality hinges on several decisive conceptual points:

  • Asymmetric temporal orientation: The causal sequence admits only a single direction toward the future. The idea that a state not yet realized (the telos) could exert a causal pull or guidance on the present constitutes a logical inversion unsustainable by physical inquiry.

  • Dynamic sufficiency of local interactions: A system’s initial conditions, together with force fields, energy exchanges, and thermodynamic laws, provide a complete and self-sufficient description of any transformation. Regular phenomena do not occur for the sake of a global benefit or result, but emerge as a necessary consequence of local micro-interactions.

  • Complexity as a retroactive effect: Where ancient philosophy saw the operation of an immanent end —such as in the morphology of living organisms— modern biology recognizes the a posteriori outcome of natural selection and genetic information. The apparent teleology of biological order is the contingent result of a process of differential stability, not its motivational premise.

With all due respect to the “maestro di color che sanno”, the elimination of the final cause has not reduced nature to a chaotic aggregate; rather, it has revealed its structural coherence: the capacity of physical systems to generate complexity and organization from mechanical dynamics devoid of any final orientation.

please, rate this post

Why Does Epistemology Presuppose Ontology?

The idea that Nature always acts for a purpose goes back to Aristotle (the final cause, the “that-for-the-sake-of-which”) and for centuries guided the way we interpret the world: for Aristotle, to know something also meant knowing its end.

When we ask ourselves how it is possible to know things, we realize that every theory of knowledge —every epistemology—inevitably rests on the very nature of reality, that is, on ontology. We cannot establish how we know without first presupposing what there is to know and what its objective structure is. In this respect, Aristotle remains relevant today.

However, modern science and philosophy marked an epochal turning point precisely by overcoming Aristotelian teleology and any form of cosmic finalism. They showed that explaining order and efficiency does not require an intentional design or an intrinsic goal, but merely the rigorous repetition of physical laws and, in the case of living organisms, evolutionary processes of adaptation. This shift demonstrates just how tight the link between being and knowing is: by changing our image of reality, the criteria by which we know it have also changed.

For anyone investigating natural phenomena today, the intellectual challenge remains the same as in the past, yet with its assumptions inverted: to comprehend the immanent regularities of physical processes by stripping them of any teleological projection. Investigating Nature no longer means deciphering a design or tracing an ultimate purpose, but questioning the causal web that sustains reality, accepting that the coherence of phenomena requires no intention to realize itself and be understood.

After all, even the rejection of a purpose is an ontological choice, and from it flows our way of knowing. The same applies to those who, in the name of science, reintroduce a purpose into Nature: this is not an empirical result, but an assumption that ought to be declared as such.

please, rate this post

Zeno, Logos, and Infinity

The so-called Eleatic challenge launched by Parmenides of Elea (about 520-450) against traditional cosmogonies through his monism was taken up by his disciple Zeno (also of Elea, 489-431). Zeno pushed the logos to its extremes by formulating paradoxes aimed at proving, for instance, the logical impossibility of motion if one failed to accept the foundational principle of being as a single, unified whole. The most famous is that of swift-footed Achilles and the tortoise (slow-footed?): in my own words, “Even if Achilles gives a head start (in space or time) to a tortoise in a race, for every interval Achilles covers, the tortoise will move ahead (even if by a smaller distance than Achilles). By imagining increasingly smaller intervals of movement for Achilles, the tortoise keeps advancing in every instance, meaning Achilles can never overtake it.”

The applied logos SEEMS consistent, but with a bit of mathematics, one can expose the flaw in this reasoning. Let us look at an example using distances.

Imagine Achilles runs 10 times faster than the tortoise and grants it a 10-meter head start.
For every advancement Achilles makes, the tortoise will have covered 1/10th of that distance. “For every” means we can sum all these (infinite) intervals together. We can thus write the formula for the total distance
D = head start + displacements covered by Achilles as:
D = 10 + 1 + 1/10 + 1/100 + 1/1000 + … to infinity, which is written as
D = 10 + ∑n=0∞ (1/10)n = 10 ∑n=0∞ (1/10)n .

This is a series of the form ∑n=0∞ qn, which converges if | q | < 1 (as in this case, where q = 0.1), yielding the value 1/(1 − q) .
We can easily compute D> = 100/9 ≈ 11.11 meters as the distance at which Achilles catches up with the tortoise.

Good old Zeno could hardly have imagined, nearly 2,500 years ago, that a sum of infinitely many terms could yield a finite number; however, as mentioned, his aim was not mathematical but philosophical (a term that was actually still anachronistic back then).

It is fascinating to note that, although a concept analogous to convergent series was tackled by Archimedes of Syracuse (in the quadrature of the parabola) just a couple of centuries later, the conceptual constraints surrounding infinity (potential vs. actual) and the absence of the concept of the limit left Zeno’s paradoxes unresolved until Augustin-Louis Cauchy (1789-1857) in the 19th century.

please, rate this post

Parmenides on Being: that which is (τὸ ἐόν)

English summary. A short reflection, written as a study exercise, on a few lines of Parmenides’ poem On Nature (DK fr. 8, vv. 6–11), in which the goddess rules out that what-is (τὸ ἐόν) could ever have come into being. The lines are read both exegetically and, in modern terms, as early uses of principles we now call non-contradiction, excluded middle and sufficient reason, against the background of the Eleatic challenge to earlier cosmogonies. The full text is in Italian.


[1a] [riguardo all’essere, (τὸ ἐόν)] quale sua nascita cercherai?
[1b, c] Come, da dove può essere cresciuto?
[2] Da ciò che non è non te lo lascerò
né dire né pensare, [2a] perché non è dicibile
né pensabile che non sia.
[3] [Inoltre] Quale necessità lo avrebbe indotto
a generarsi dopo piuttosto che prima, avendo inizio da ciò che non è?
[4] [Conclusione] È così necessario che o esista in assoluto oppure non esista del tutto.


La visione di Parmenide si pone in contrasto con le cosmogonie dei pensatori detti presocratici. Questi versi sono parte del poema nel quale egli riporta come racconto di una dea la via alla verità (aletheia). Questa rivelazione è fondata sul logos, la razionalità che spinge agli estremi la logica interpretativa, diversamente dall’esperienza che viene ingannata dai sensi. Il soggetto sottinteso del frammento è ciò che è (τὸ ἐόν), considerato da Parmenide: ingenerato, eterno, immobile, unico e finito; così dalla dea ne sono definiti gli attributi -che chiama indizi (semata)- al kouros/Parmenide, alcuni precisati nel frammento riportato.

Si possono distinguere due possibili tipologie di argomentazioni nel frammento citato: quelle esegetiche legate più strettamente al testo e quelle legate al logos [*] e alla massima coerenza razionale (i primi passi di una nuova disciplina), espresse in termini ‘moderni’.
[1a,b,c] L’indagine sull’essere potrebbe iniziare dalla sua nascita e crescita, così farebbe una cosmogonia.
[2] Ma la dea (ovvero il logos) non consente al kouros di pensare e di dire che ciò che è possa derivare da ciò che non è, perché pensando ciò che non è per poterne parlare lo si tratterebbe come qualcosa che è [2a] quindi per coerenza razionale questo è non dicibile né pensabile.
Viene applicato un principio di non contraddizione [*].
[3] La domanda retorica evidenzia la mancanza della necessità per ciò che è di generarsi, dopo o prima, da ciò che non è, non solo per le ragioni del verso precedente ma anche per il suo non appartenere al tempo (precisato in versi successivi).
Si evidenzia anche la mancanza di una ragione sufficiente [*].
[4] La conclusione ricorda che la possibilità dell’esistenza è considerata binaria, quindi applica il principio del terzo escluso [*] e l’implicazione che ciò che è può solo essere, perchè è “necessario” che sia.
Quindi è una ragione sufficiente [*].

Da un punto di vista storico, tema del frammento è la ‘provocazione del logos‘, la razionalità. La cosiddetta sfida eleatica di Parmenide contro le cosmogonie, rispetto alle quali rappresenta uno ‘spartiacque’ del pensiero antico.
Le cosmogonie infatti non sono logicamente sostenibili perché passano dal ‘prima’ al ‘dopo’ senza una ragione sufficiente.

please, rate this post

AI as a Boltzmann brain: the illusion of knowledge cancelling the future

This reflection stems from a re-reading of my post on the Boltzmann Brain (see The Boltzmann Brain – an epistemological provocation). While the process today is evolving very rapidly, I believe it makes sense to analyze it from an evolutionary perspective.

The use of AI is certainly an effective support, but we must distinguish between contexts. Enhancing research within an environment of high-level expertise is one thing; using it to obtain basic answers by ‘the youth’ is quite another. The latter prevents the formation of a critical spirit and the necessary ‘fatigue of learning’. Without this granular foundation of skills, more complex elaborations become impossible.

Demographics are unforgiving. Soon, the figures trained on the fundamentals will disappear, replaced by those who never had to struggle to learn. Considering the ‘average’ person, it is easy to predict an immense cognitive impoverishment that will lead to the final decay of our civilization. Technology will remain standing, but without the updating of fundamental principles—the theoretical foundations upon which it is built—it will become obsolete and insufficient.
This is not just the fault of scientific research. The reasons why we still use fossil fuels, rare earth batteries, or nuclear fission do not depend solely on technical limits, but on choices of power that go beyond the official narrative.

I do not believe there is adequate awareness of the ‘toxic’ role of AI. The global project is clear: to create a ‘cerebrally’ undifferentiated anthropic mass, useful as a voting weight and workforce for as long as it costs less than machines. Indeed, I believe that ‘bipedal mammals’ are already cheaper than automation today, yet they are still endowed with a residual self-determination (really residual, as demonstrated during the Covid period).

There is also a parallel with religions. Religions do not have to be rational: the more unbelievable a story is, the more it is believed. They function very well because they provide ‘trusted’ answers, not true ones. No one wants the truth; people just want to be told they are not the only ones thinking something. Social platforms thrive on this. In the same way, AI algorithms provide the answers they ‘must’ provide, based on non-transparent priorities. I do not blame the software, which is just a statistical routine, nor do I blame those who write it. The Puppet Masters sit on the upper floors and manage the triggers.

How to save ourselves?
There is probably no salvation for us ‘standard bipeds’. But history teaches that civilizations always rise from their ashes, perhaps rediscovering a glorious past after centuries of oblivion. I trust in this cycle for humanity. In the meantime, I only hope that the time I have left “non mi sia grave” to borrow from Leopardi.

please, rate this post

Portrait of an epistemological stagnation

We have grown accustomed to being ‘subjected to’ scientific progress as if it were a triumphal and unstoppable march. We live surrounded by a pervasive technology that grants us the illusion of an ever-deepening knowledge of reality. Yet, if we look at the foundations of theoretical physics, the landscape that appears is one of a desolate epistemological stagnation.
For over fifty years, fundamental physics has failed to produce a true ontological revolution. We have confirmed theories born in the last century—such as the Higgs boson from the 1960s or Einstein’s gravitational waves from the beginning of the century, the only two true demonstrations of fundamental theories in recent decades—but we have not given birth to a single new idea that has been proven real (see What’s wrong with scientific research according to Sabine Hossenfelder). On the contrary, we have retreated into a sort of ‘maintenance of paradigms’ (in the Kuhnian sense), adding mathematical patches to models that no longer function (see Kuhn’s “The Structure of Scientific Revolutions” in a nutshell).

The Trap of the ‘Millennium Problem’

A perfect example of this drift is the celebrated Millennium Problem regarding the Navier-Stokes equations (see A pure mathematical version of the Clay Mathematics Institute’s Navier-Stokes Millennium Problem). We are asked to prove whether a ‘smooth’ (continuous) solution can explode into a mathematical singularity. But who does this research truly benefit?
There is a certain arrogance in demanding that the mathematics of the absolute continuum—a tool invented three hundred years ago—must be the faithful mirror of a reality we know to be intrinsically granular. Seeking regularity or singularity in Navier-Stokes is an exercise in the internal consistency of an axiomatic system, a ‘mathematical little game’ that adds nothing to our understanding of matter.
It is a restaging of the late 19th-century ultraviolet catastrophe: classical physics predicted the emission of infinite energy from a black body because it assumed energy was infinitely divisible. Max Planck did not ‘solve’ the calculation problem that diverged; he changed the logic, introducing the quantum of energy—a granular discretization (see Planck’s photon distribution function). Today, persisting in the search for regularity in continuous fluid dynamic models without accepting the logical (and physical) limits of that language is like trying to measure an atom with a ruler: the error is not in the mathematical calculation, but in the model adopted.

The Ptolemaic universe of dark matter

If Navier-Stokes is a dead end for brilliant minds, modern cosmology has become a triumph of epicycles. Kuhn taught us sixty years ago that when a paradigm enters a crisis, the scientific community does not abandon it immediately, but instead begins to ‘save’ it with ‘ad hoc’ hypotheses.
Thus, to make General Relativity equations square with a universe that moves differently than predicted, dark matter and dark energy were invented. We do not see them, we do not know what they are, and we do not understand their nature. They are ‘magical patches’ necessary to prop up models that we are unable to interpret. We are planning trips to Mars using a modernized Ptolemaic system, convinced that adding an invisible epicycle is nobler than admitting we have failed to understand the nature of gravity on a large scale (see Note for laymen – what is the dark matter?).

The Deception of Technological Progress

The common objection is: “How can you speak of stagnation when Artificial Intelligence and silicon dominate the world?”
Here lies the fundamental misunderstanding. Technology is not fundamental science; it is the exploitation of past discoveries. Computers are based on the quantum mechanics of the 1920s and 30s; our rockets on 19th-century thermodynamics. Technology is the engineering that refines the already known, but the theory upon which it is founded remains old—tremendously old. We are utilizing maps that ignore 95% of the territory, or that are incapable of observing it in its true reality.

The Tyranny of the ‘Barons’ and the veto of the paradigm

Why do we not move forward? Because knowledge has become a hostage to a feudal academic structure. The ‘Barons’ of the paradigm are slaves to their own careers and the consensus of the community. Risk is not funded. Anyone proposing a sensible cosmological model that does not include invisible ‘ghosts’ is isolated, denied publication, and stripped of funding.
The system prefers to distract superior minds by challenging them with inessential problems—like Navier-Stokes singularities or calculating the galactic halos of magical components—rather than facing the terrifying uncertainty of a paradigm shift. We are moving backward, not forward, because we have lost the ability to see the problem before calculating the solution.

Conclusion: seeing beyond the fence

Mathematics is indifferent to the survival of the solution, but we should not be. The task of research is not to balance the books of a useless abstraction, but to find the correct language to describe reality.
The result regarding the Navier-Stokes singularity will not change the empirical efficacy of the laws of dynamics. It would perhaps establish (with due respect to Gödel) whether the continuous model is a coherent language or if it is destined to succumb to its own abstraction.
The true challenge is having the courage to admit that our reference models do not describe reality, and that it is necessary to explore new descriptions of nature beyond a “déjà vu that simply ‘does not work’ (by the very admission of those who continue to support it).
While waiting for a visionary genius to find a better description of reality, we could, in the meantime, make room for the visionaries who see beyond the fence…

please, rate this post