Eddington luminosity and limits to stellar growth

The Eddington luminosity (Lₑ) (named after Arthur Stanley Eddington, 1882-1944), also known as the Eddington limit, is the growth limit of a structure that is in hydrostatic equilibrium (see Figure 1), balancing the outward radiation pressure with the inward gravitational pull.


Figure 1 – Hydrostatic equilibrium


The relationship for the luminosity limit can be easily derived, obtaining:
[1]    L ≤ 4π c G M / k = Lₑ
where  G  is the universal gravitational constant,  M  is the mass of the object,  c  is the speed of light, and  k  is the opacity (ability to absorb radiation) of the material that makes up the object.
As a function of solar parameters, in the case of the model consisting of ionized hydrogen, [1] can be expressed as:
[2]    Lₑ ≈ 3.2 * 10⁴ (M/M๏) L๏
where   M๏   and   L๏   are the mass and luminosity of the Sun.

In the very hot core of massive stars (or in accretion disks of black holes), opacity is independent of frequency and temperature, is related to Thomson scattering (see Thomson scattering on Wikipedia for more informations) of free electrons, and can be expressed as:
[3]    kₑₛ = σₜ nₑ / ρ
where σₜ is the Thomson cross section for electrons, nₑ is the number density of electrons, and  ρ  is the density of the medium.
To consider the more general case of models also consisting of helium and metals, the general relationship is expressed as a function of the mass fraction (X) of hydrogen, and the  [3] becomes:
[4]    kₑₛ = σₜ (1+X) / 2 mₚ ≈ 0.2 (1+X)    cm² / gr
where  mₚ  is the mass of the proton.
Therefore, in the case of a model consisting only of helium, Eddington luminosity would double (with   X=0 ,  [4]  is halved and  [1]  is doubled).
Relationships can also be derived for cases of models that are not fully ionized or colder (for less massive stars), or for highly energetic radiation (e.g., gamma rays as in black hole accretion disks), but these are beyond the scope of this note.

What is notable is that this physical limit explains why we do not observe infinitely large stars; beyond a certain mass limit, the luminosity is such that it disrupts the star.
The Eddington luminosity also defines the maximum rate at which a black hole can grow: if matter falls too quickly, the light emitted repels it back.

please, rate this post

A sharp presentation of a quantum mechanics course

Not all professors are so explicit in presenting a quantum mechanics course, which is objectively very challenging. A medal for intellectual honesty to this professor!
(yes, it’s an old video, but it’s still worth watching ; )

link  Presentation of a quantum mechanics course

please, rate this post

Snell’s law and the causes of refraction

Let us recall Snell’s well-known law, which describes the phenomenon of refraction:
– a ray of light undergoes a deviation when it passes from one transparent medium to another with a different refractive index (see Figure 2).


Figure 1 – Snell law

 

Figure 2 – Refraction example


Mathematically (see Figure 1):
[1]    n’ sin(θ’) = n” sin(θ”)
where  n’ ,  n”  are the refractive indices of the two transparent media,  θ’ ,  θ”  are the angles of incidence and refraction (measured relative to normal at the interface between the media).
In other words, given two media, the ratio between the respective sines of the angles of incidence and refraction is constant.
A first proof can be obtained by applying Pierre de Fermat’s (1601-1665) principle of least time, namely that light follows the path that requires the least time to travel from one point to another. Attached below is the simple geometric-analytical proof (in italian):

pdf  Fermat_Snell_geometric-analytical demonstration

Okay, this relationship (perhaps already studied in the 10th century by the Persian mathematician Ibn Sahl) is certainly interesting, but what is the physical motivation for this constant quantity? It is necessary to identify where this regularity lies.
The reasons derive directly from Maxwell’s equations, the fundamental laws describing the interaction between electric and magnetic fields.
From these, it follows that the boundary conditions require that the tangential components of the electric field and magnetic field be continuous across the separation surface. Therefore, the phase of the incident, (reflected,) and transmitted wave must be the same along this boundary.

The assumption that the frequency ( ν ) of the incident light remains constant (i.e., that it is independent of the medium in which it propagates) can also be understood by considering that if this were not the case, it would lose coherence as it crossed the surface between the two media, probably transforming the image observed through the separation surface into a uniform grey color, which is not observed.
Furthermore, since the energy associated with incident photons is  E = h ν , where  h  is the Planck constant, the same conservation of energy tells us that the frequency cannot change.
Quantistic note: this consideration refers to a single photon, which would change color (towards red) if it lost energy (phenomenon that does not occur for all observed refracted photons). Considering a beam of photons, however, it may be that the second medium causes absorption of the incident light, thus a decrease in total energy, but this concerns the entire beam that absorbs some photons completely and not the individual photons.

Considering the wave vectors  k’  (incident) and  k”  (refracted) associated with their respective phases, and equating their projections on the separation interface, we obtain:
[2]     k’ sin(θ’) = k” sin(θ”)
but  k = ω / v  , where  ω  is the angular frequency of the electromagnetic wave of the incident light,  v  is the velocity in the medium, and defining the refractive index  n = c / v  (derived from the constants  ε₀  and  μ₀  of the medium using Maxwell’s equations, where  c =  1/√(ε₀ μ₀)  ), from  [2]  we finally obtain  [1] .

please, rate this post

The three-body problem and the five Lagrangian points

Joseph-Louis Lagrange (1736-1813) was a great mathematician of the 18th century. His main studies on mechanics led him to tackle the gravitational three-body problem, which, however, remains unsolved to this day because the system is inherently chaotic and unpredictable in the long term, as small initial variations cause drastically different results.
Lagrange found the equilibrium solutions (the five Lagrangian points, see figure taken from the ESA website) for the system in the simplified yet highly interesting case where the third body has negligible mass compared to the other two (e.g., the Sun, a planet, and an asteroid or an artificial satellite). The first three points (L1, L2, L3) had already been found by Leonhard Euler (1707-1783), another huge mathematician of the 18th century, while Lagrange found the so-called ‘triangular’ points (L4, L5), because they form perfect equilateral triangles with the two main bodies.
For details about these points, please refer to the easy explanations on the
link  ESA (European Space Agency) website.

Obviously, Lagrange could never have known about the evidence supporting his conjecture (it was only in 1906 that astronomers confirmed his theory by discovering Trojan asteroids captured at points L4 and L5 of Jupiter’s orbit) or its current usefulness in positioning our space exploration vehicles.
Thanks to their ‘gravitational stability’, which saves positioning energy (and in the case of L2 also provides partial shielding from the Sun), it is conceivable that, in the future of space exploration, advanced bases for deep space exploration will be located at Lagrangian points.

 

The 5 Lagrangian points, from the link  ESA (European Space Agency) website; the orbits of points L1 and L2 are not to scale, the distance from Earth is about 1/100 of the radius of Earth’s orbit.

Lagrangian points

please, rate this post

Dedekind’s theorem: a reconsideration of the demonstration

I had second thoughts about the draft proof already posted here.
Using a couple of theorems (called 1.1.3 and 1.1.8, attached), the proof becomes much simpler and more straightforward.
But I think I am justified in my oversight, as I studied these theorems so long ago that Tim Berners Lee had yet to invent the www   ; )

pdf_ita  Brussi 2026_Theorem_1.1.3 and 1.1.8

pdf_ita  Brussi 2026_Dedekind theorem 2

 

please, rate this post

Why do stars twinkle at night and planets do not?

planets do not twinkle
This fact, known for millennia, allows even the layman to immediately distinguish in the night sky one of the planets of the Solar System (Venus, Mars, Jupiter, Saturn) from the stars with the naked eye.
These light sources, observed from the Earth’s surface, exhibit two main characteristic behaviors due to the same cause, atmospheric turbulence:
– slight oscillations in position (appreciable with good binoculars or a small telescope)
– intensity twinkling (typically only stars).
Other effects, especially when the source is close to the horizon, are: chromatic twinkling (color changes), atmospheric extinction (decrease in brightness), reddening, and twinkling of the planets.
Atmospheric turbulence at low altitudes (the first tens or hundreds of meters) is responsible for positional oscillations, together with turbulence at medium altitudes (6-8 km) where air cells of different temperatures and densities mix, while turbulence near the tropopause (8-12 km) associated with jet streams is responsible for scintillation.

It is the optical dimensions of the sources that make the difference in the scintillation, based on their interaction with turbulence cells, which also vary in size. Jet streams determine large cells, ranging from tens to hundreds of meters, but turbulence follows Kolmogorov’s cascade model (see Figure 1), dissipating the initial kinetic energy into increasingly smaller vortices, down to the order of centimeters or millimeters, eventually dissipating into heat. It is precisely these microcells that deflect the point-like light from stellar sources, but they have a mediated effect in the case of optically larger sources such as planets, which involve multiple cells. The final effect is the stabilization of the source’s light, which therefore appears non-twinkling.


Figure 1 – An illustrative sketch of turbulence transformation according to Kolmogorov’s cascade model

turbolence

please, rate this post

An easy note on the chain rule in differential equations

The chain rule in differential equations is a small but powerful trick often used to derive composite functions by finding the derivative of the outer function while keeping the inner function unchanged.
For example, the expression  dy/dx  can be rewritten as:
[1]    dy/dx = dy/du * du/dx  .
In this way, we can obtain a derivative with respect to a variable that is more useful, for example because we know its value (possibly in a simpler formal expression, or already known), or is easier to integrate.
In simple terms, this means transforming the rate of change of  x  with respect to  y  into the product of the rate of change of  u  with respect to  y  and the rate of change of  x  with respect to  u .
Regarding rules for deriving functions, the chain rule leads to the proof that if  F(x) = f(g(x)) , its derivative is:
[2]    F'(x) = f'(g(x) * g'(x)  .

But while this rule for deriving functions is used every day without thinking about it, the chain rule can be a useful trick in solving many physics problems when we don’t know the direct rate of change between two variables.
A simple example of its use in astrophysics is in the study of star formation and Jeans’ Mass (the critical threshold required for a cloud of interstellar gas and dust to collapse under its own gravity to form stars). The chain rule is used to convert acceleration into a form that depends on position rather than time, making the differential equation integrable. In formal terms, as in  [1] , we can write:
[3]    d²R/dt² = dv/dt = dv/dR * dR/dt = v * dv/dR  ,
where  v = dR/dt  .
In this case, this substitution allows us to integrate the equation of motion with respect to radius  R  to determine the free-fall time of a collapsing gas cloud (off-topic calculation omitted).


collapsing gas cloud
Collapsing gas cloud(source accademiadellestelle.org)

please, rate this post

The equal sign “=”

Some considerations for true beginners.

The equal sign “=” is a mathematical symbol (coined by Welsh mathematician Robert Recorde in 1557) of two parallel horizontal lines used to show that two expressions have the same value or are identical.
It is taught very early on in elementary school, but I don’t think the power of its deep meaning is explained well. At least, that’s what we can see from the difficulties experienced by slightly older students.

Equal means exactly equal. What is on the left of the “=” sign has the same value as what is on the right. So if there is a symbol on the left and a number on the right, in that context that symbol is worth exactly the amount indicated. And if two symbols are equal, they can be used interchangeably. Trivial, but a source of great doubt for those who have not fully grasped the basic concept.

From a formal point of view, the equal sign satisfies the following conditions:
– Reflexive Property: any value is equal to itself,  a = a
– Symmetric property: if  a = b  then  b = a  (the order of the expressions can be swapped without changing the truth)
– Transitive Property: if  a = b  and  b = c  then  a = c

– Substitution Property: informally, this just means that if  a = b , then  a  can replace  b  in any mathematical expression or formula without changing its meaning; formally, for every  a  and  b , and any formula  ϕ(x)  with a free variable  x , if  a = b , then  ϕ(a)  implies  ϕ(b) ; we can call this a function application.

Even without going into further detail, these simple properties allow us, for example, to solve first-degree equations directly. They allow us to invert formulas simply by adding or multiplying the same quantity on both sides of the equation. OK, taking care not to divide by zero.
If the unknown quantities (the so-called variables) are of a higher degree, things get more complicated, but the effectiveness of “=” remains the same.
A powerful little trick based on this is to use new variables to replace more complicated expressions or those with higher powers.

please, rate this post

Dedekind’s theorem: a draft proof

A draft written in Italian proves the existence and uniqueness of an element that separates two non-empty sets representing the field of real numbers.
This allows us to prove that the real numbers are a complete space (i.e., that every Cauchy sequence is convergent).

Note: in the case of irrational numbers instead of rational numbers, it does not work because they are not complete, i.e., it is not possible to define an element that is an extreme.
In layman’s terms, one could say that if rational numbers are removed from the real numbers to obtain irrational numbers, then ‘gaps remain’ and completeness no longer exists.
upgrade:  a reconsideration of the demonstration

pdf_ita  Brussi 2026_Dedekind theorem

please, rate this post