The three-body problem and the five Lagrangian points

Joseph-Louis Lagrange (1736-1813) was a great mathematician of the 18th century. His main studies on mechanics led him to tackle the gravitational three-body problem, which, however, remains unsolved to this day because the system is inherently chaotic and unpredictable in the long term, as small initial variations cause drastically different results.
Lagrange found the equilibrium solutions (the five Lagrangian points, see figure taken from the ESA website) for the system in the simplified yet highly interesting case where the third body has negligible mass compared to the other two (e.g., the Sun, a planet, and an asteroid or an artificial satellite). The first three points (L1, L2, L3) had already been found by Leonhard Euler (1707-1783), another huge mathematician of the 18th century, while Lagrange found the so-called ‘triangular’ points (L4, L5), because they form perfect equilateral triangles with the two main bodies.
For details about these points, please refer to the easy explanations on the
link  ESA (European Space Agency) website.

Obviously, Lagrange could never have known about the evidence supporting his conjecture (it was only in 1906 that astronomers confirmed his theory by discovering Trojan asteroids captured at points L4 and L5 of Jupiter’s orbit) or its current usefulness in positioning our space exploration vehicles.
Thanks to their ‘gravitational stability’, which saves positioning energy (and in the case of L2 also provides partial shielding from the Sun), it is conceivable that, in the future of space exploration, advanced bases for deep space exploration will be located at Lagrangian points.

 

The 5 Lagrangian points, from the link  ESA (European Space Agency) website; the orbits of points L1 and L2 are not to scale, the distance from Earth is about 1/100 of the radius of Earth’s orbit.

Lagrangian points

please, rate this post

References for laymen: Archimedes’ hydrostatic principle

Archimedes of Syracuse (287-212) was perhaps one of humanity’s greatest mathematical geniuses. He is remembered for the principle of hydrostatic thrust, the screw pump, and war machines, but his most advanced studies were on conics and mathematical methods for calculating surfaces and volumes (e.g., of sphere). These are considered among the highest achievements of ancient science and, although they lack modern formal rigor, they represent the direct precursors of the concept of limits and integral calculus (independently developed by Sir Isaac Newton and Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz in the late 17th century). See, for example, Lucio Russo, Archimedes: A Great Ancient Scientist (Carocci Editore, 2019).

One day, my young son asked me, “Why do ships that are heavy and made of iron float?” I couldn’t explain the density of water to him, but I found a good answer for a child: “Because they weigh less than the water they displace.”
This is exactly Archimedes’ principle of hydrostatic thrust, which in more complicated terms is expressed as: “A body immersed in a fluid experiences an upward thrust equal to the weight of the volume of fluid displaced.” So if this is greater than the weight of the body, it floats.

We can express Archimedes’ principle of hydrostatic thrust (force) F(A) using the following formula:
[1]    F(A) = m * g = ρ(fluid) * V(displaced) * g
where  m =  ρ *  V  is the mass,  g  is the acceleration due to gravity,  ρ  represents the density, and  V  represents the volume of fluid displaced by the body.
For this reason, any body also ‘weighs’ according to the density of the fluid in which it is immersed. The greater the density, the greater the hydrostatic thrust and the lower the weight of the body.

As an example, if an iron nail (which, due to its shape, does not seem to be able to float like a ship by displacing a lot of fluid) were placed in a container with liquid mercury, which has a density almost double that of iron, the nail would float at the level of the weight of mercury displaced. Calculations show that it would be immersed just over half its volume (about 58%).


In this video, we can see how an iron anvil floats in mercury because the density of iron (7.87 g/cm³) is almost half that of mercury (13.55 g/cm³) (source: Wonder of science on X channel).


Another famous example of buoyancy is that of hot air balloons: they float exactly like a ship because the volume of fluid (atmospheric air) they displace weighs more (is denser) than that contained in the balloon, which is heated with a burner (and is therefore less dense).


An hot air balloon (source: freedome.it)

mongolfiera

please, rate this post

References for laymen: an experiment to verify the law of falling bodies

The first observational measurements on the law of falling bodies were made by Galileo Galilei (1564-1642).
The famous law, considering the distance d traveled during the fall, is:
[1]    d = g t² / 2
where  g  is a constant representing the local gravitational acceleration (on Earth a mean value is  g = 9.8 m/s² ), and  t  is the time elapsed. In more easily observable terms, the fall time can be measured reversing the relationship  [1] :
[2]    t = √(2d/g)  .
Galileo predicted (inspired by what Domingo de Soto had already conceived in 1551) that all bodies follow this law regardless of their mass, studying rolling balls (rather than dropping them from the famous Tower of Pisa). However, everyday experience tells us that light bodies fall more slowly: this is simply due to the friction of the fluid in which they are immersed (e.g., air).

A rather expensive experiment was reported to have been carried out on the Moon, when a hammer and a feather were dropped and touched the ground at the same time (astronaut David Scott on August 2, 1971).
I propose the following more economical experiment: drop a coin that is not too small, for example a 2 euro coin, flat on its face, placing a small piece of paper, e.g. 5 mm in diameter, on top of it. A good height would be half a meter. You can observe that the piece of paper reaches the ground at the same time as the coin, which prevents the air from slowing it down.
You could also place the piece of paper in a transparent container that you then drop, but this would make it less clear to observe.

As a side note, it can be observed that a body in free fall accelerates until this acceleration equals the acceleration of gravity, due to the mass of the body (tipically the Earth) on which it is falling (possibly slowed down by air resistance, known as drag force). Once this is reached, the speed of fall, known as terminal velocity, remains constant. On contrary, a body falling in a vacuum never reaches terminal velocity because there is no drag force; it accelerates indefinitely as long as it is falling.

please, rate this post

Note for laymen – what is the dark matter?

Let’s consider a disc galaxy with billions of stars forming the disc, which rotates (the Andromeda galaxy in the photo, to give a well-known example). We can consider for each of these stars that the centripetal acceleration
[1]    a’ = v²/R
is equal to the gravitational acceleration
[2]    a” = G M/R²
therefore from  [1] = [2]  we obtain:
[3]    v = √(G M/R)
where  v  is the local velocity of the source considered,  R  is its distance from the galactic center,  G  is the gravitational constant,  M  is the total mass contained within the radius  R  (which determines the gravitational attraction).
Measuring the rotational velocities of galaxies is relatively easy, if they are not seen face on, and it is generally observed that throughout the disk the rotational velocities of the sources (stars but also gas clouds) are almost constant. Therefore, from relation  [3]  it follows that the mass  M  must increase in proportion to the radius  R , since  G  is a constant. Indeed, the mass contained within the radius  R  increases as  R  increases, but what is observed is not sufficient to justify the constant value of  v . These considerations leads to the hypothesis that there is a substance that is invisible and non-baryonic in nature (i.e., not made up of protons and neutrons, which are not detected) that manifests itself only through gravitational behavior, which is called dark matter.


Processed photograph of M31, Andromeda. It was not possible to obtain the author of this beautiful photograph.


Andromeda

please, rate this post

Here I am

After a hiatus from 2021, I’m resuming my online presence with this small collection of suggestions, seeking intellectual dialogue. Let me know what you think in the comments or via email.
Thanks

p.s. I posted with the dates of the original documents

 

 

That's me

please, rate this post

My thesis work

My thesis work (written in italian) is published in the University of Padova archive:
pdf_ita  Brussi 2025_Epistemology of time and cosmological interpretations

As an appendix to the same thesis I put a first development draft of the non-standard framework, which, after significant revisions, later became my work
link  The URD Framework.


Abstract
The aims of this study on time are first to explore its ontological meaning in the historical developments that have accompanied its interpretative evolution, and then to examine some theoretical critical issues raised by recent literature. With some original theses, some alternative explanations for the expansion of the universe are then analyzed, which the current interpretation claims to be observed experimentally, by means of a model based on the ‘specific time’ of photons as an alternative to the ‘universal time’. Furthermore, it is hypothesized a model that considers the presence of an energy density in the cosmic fluid (called aether) that interacts with the incident radiation, thus determining a redshift effect in the wavelength, or an even longer time for the same radiation to diffuse. The consistency of ‘specific time’ has been verified with Minkowski spacetime, with Einstein’s principles of special relativity, and with Friedman’s equations of cosmic dynamics. Having demonstrated the fallacy of this ‘specific time’ hypothesis, the positive conclusion is that there is no need to postulate a universal time. Once one is defined, its uniqueness or universality can be demonstrated (within the limits of the adopted models). To complement the study, possible causes of the redshift, alternative to the standard cosmological model, were analyzed. It has been taken in consideration the hypothesis that the same universe behaves like a black body, emitting a radiation (the cosmic microwave radiation) that can interact with the observed photons coming from remote sources, attenuating their energy and determining their redshift. A cross section for photons, and a model for photon-photon interactions that respects the law of conservation of energy have therefore been hypothesized. As a basis for the conjectures, direct observational evidence was considered, not interpreted by means of theories, obtaining (from the comparison with other standard candles) better distance estimates than the official ones based on Hubble’s law. This addendum is included as an Annex, believing that the same conjectures and some original models can represent a reference for future in-depth studies.

The work is written in Italian (1.8 MB):

pdf_ita  Brussi 2025_Epistemologia del tempo e interpretazioni cosmologiche

please, rate this post

What’s wrong with scientific research according to Sabine Hossenfelder

An interesting speech by Sabine Hossenfelder: “A few words on some well-known and perhaps lesser-known problems in scientific research and what others have said about them.”

In essence: “Scientific research has big problems, and it’s getting worse”.

 

please, rate this post

A historical photo

Solvay Conference on Quantum Mechanics, 1927

Solvay Conference on Quantum Mechanics, 1927 (photo by Benjamin Couprie, Institut International de Physique Solvay, Bruxelles, Belgium; I have slightly restored this photo, usually available in a lower detail level).

From behind, left to right: Auguste Piccard, Émile Henriot, Paul Ehrenfest, Édouard Herzen, Théophile de Donder, Erwin Schrödinger, Jules-Émile Verschaffelt, Wolfgang Pauli, Werner Heisenberg, Ralph Howard Fowler, Léon Brillouin, Peter Debye, Martin Knudsen, William Lawrence Bragg, Hendrik Anthony Kramers, Paul Dirac, Arthur Compton, Louis de Broglie, Max Born, Niels Bohr, Irving Langmuir, Max Planck, Marie Skłodowska Curie, Hendrik Lorentz, Albert Einstein, Paul Langevin, Charles-Eugène Guye, Charles Thomson Rees Wilson, Owen Willans Richardson

please, rate this post